Why do Muslims Lose..?

[Star]

You repeat the same points over and over and over and over again - they have been responded to on many occasions - one only needs to go through the numerous loooong exchanges there have been with you - in which many of the members of this forum have responded and - in my opinion (obviously not yours), and given the response on this forum, in the opinion of most who've come across these discussions - they have answered convicingly.


But you will persistently cut and paste - cut and paste - cut and paste from the Freeminder articles. All the time you are portraying a specific "understanding" of the Quran - whilst trying to pass of the Freeminders as a disparate collective as opposed to the cult that they actually are.


And if one reads some of these Articles and the comments made by the creators in respect to Muslims, the responses you receive are relatively mild in comparison.


Furthermore - for a group to continuously attack Muslims - surely they should be prepared to explain and justify their own views first. It is in this aspect - when your own views are questioned and queried that you seem to take personal disgust.

[Amar-Sonar-Bangla]

Me no ishfik inglish!

Does one need a good grasp of English to discuss Islamic ideas. Arabic? I understand the need for. But were all Bangali's here and I'm sure speaking in our mother tongue along wit english is enough for at least rudimentary understanding.

[hac]

Originally posted by Amar-Sonar-Bangla
Me no ishfik inglish!

Does one need a good grasp of English to discuss Islamic ideas. Arabic? I understand the need for. But were all Bangali's here and I'm sure speaking in our mother tongue along wit english is enough for at least rudimentary understanding.

No, one does not need a good grasp of English to discuss Islam. One does however need an excellent grasp of language if one is to be able to translate and interpret Qur'an and then teach others. Shamsul has been guilty on a number of occasions of making simple grammatical mistakes, yet he feels as though he is able to fully understand Qur'an. With English as bad as his, he should be the last guy to preach his understanding. Simple grammatical mistakes lead him to make profound changes to Islamic belief. When these mistakes are pointed out, they are rejected as 'another interpretation' - I don't highlight his bad lanuguage skills for any other reason that this.

He should be aware that such a book of knowledge cannot be fully understood by amateurs. Can you do a PhD without doing a degree?

[yayati]

shamsul is correct....