|
Salam,
In addition to my above post i might just add - For those who provide traditions that Mutah was forbidden.
Traditions by NECESSITY have to run in accordance with the quran not against it, otherwise they are to be ignored.
traditions can not abrogate the existing verses of Quran. Quran is always in higher authority. The traditions are always subject to check with Quran, and if they are found to be in contradiction with Quran, those contradicting traditions are rejected.
More over, the abrogated verse is either deleted from Quran by the Prophet, or if it is present in Quran, there should be another verse revealed at a later time to abrogate the previous one. In other words, the only way to establish that a verse which is present in Quran is abrogated, is to have an abrogating verse which should have been revealed after that verse, since the traditions alone can not abrogate an existing verse of Quran. Since there is no verse revealed after 4:24 abrogating it, it is still in effect.
And there are more problems with these three traditions on forbidding the temporary marriage which inshallah I will discuss when I have more time. My humble suggestion is what the Prophet recited when he allowed the Temporary marriage:
O' those who believe, do not make unlawful the good things which Allah has made lawful for you, and do not transgress. Allah does not like transgressors. (Quran 5:87)
Wassalam
Allahuma salle ala Muhammed wa alay Muhammed
|